PCF

Week in Review, March 6, 2015

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

A potential new law in California calls for greater drug pricing transparency, consumer advocacy groups and industry trade groups in Europe argue over clinical trial data transparency, a Maine law allowing the purchase of pharmaceuticals from foreign pharmacies is overruled, and the issue of off-label speech and free speech is back in the news.

In like a lion and out like a lamb; it’s hard to believe March is here. The really good news…spring is almost here as well (although looking at the seven inches of fresh snow outside the Week in Review windows, we find that hard to believe). Whether you subscribe to the meteorological or astronomical start of spring, one way or another it is/will be here this month, and that alone is reason to celebrate! We are on the downward slope of winter, folks and we couldn’t be happier. Another thing that makes us happing is sharing the news of the week with all of you, so let’s spring in to action and get this week’s Week in Review underway!

Nothing says spring like some sunshine, and nothing says sunshine like transparency laws. A California assemblyman has proposed a law that would require the disclosure of information related to the pricing of drugs. The law would apply to drugs costing $10,000 or more for a course of treatment, and companies would have to report information such as production costs, sales and marketing costs, and financial assistance provided through prescription assistance programs. If the law is passed, companies would submit annual reports to the state, and the information would be made available to the public.

Speaking of transparency and disclosure, there seems to be a kerfuffle blooming in Europe over clinical trial data transparency. Proposed rules by the European Medicines Authority (EMA) have prompted comments from industry trade groups and others regarding the confidentiality of commercial information. Industry groups have said certain data related to clinical trials could reveal trade secrets and compromise patient privacy. Consumer advocacy groups insist the more transparency the better in the name of protecting patients. In a press release, a Germany-based advocacy group accused the EMA of writing such a broad definition of commercial confidential information that the determination of what is confidential is left up the study sponsor. Two bio industry trade groups released a statement saying there should be a “deferral” for the disclosing information from Phase I trials due to the “commercial sensitivity” of the information.

Medical device manufacturer, ev3, had to spring for some past promotional issues allegedly committed by one of its recent acquisitions. The company agreed to pay $1.25 million to settle allegations that it violated the False Claims Act. The government claimed Fox Hollow Technologies, which was acquired by ev3, caused hospitals to improperly bill Medicare and Medicaid for medically unnecessary inpatient stays for patients undergoing atherectomies using a Fox Hollow device. The government alleged the company suggested the inpatient procedures in order to drive sales of the device to hospitals, thereby causing hospitals to be reimbursed more than they were entitled.

There’s been a late freeze on the Maine law that allows individuals to purchase prescription drugs from select foreign pharmacies. A federal judge has ruled the Maine law is overruled by federal law, which prohibits importing drugs from foreign countries. The decision nullifies the Maine law. The state can appeal if it chooses.

The seeds are being planted for another free speech case involving off-label statements. A federal district court in California is considering a whistleblower False Claims Act case against Millennium Pharmaceuticals in which the whistleblower claims that Millennium and Schering-Plough (now Merck) promoted a heart drug for off-label uses. In a motion to dismiss, Merck argued that the False Claims Act cannot be interpreted to prohibit the truthful, non-misleading exchange of scientific information. In making the argument, Merck sited both the Sorrell v. IMS Health and U.S. v. Caronia cases. The DOJ filed a brief with the court saying that truthful speech could be used as a basis for the False Claims Act. PhRMA filed a friend of the court brief in support of Merck’s argument.

With that, we end this “almost spring, we hope” edition of the Week in Review. Have a great week everyone!

 

Week in Review, July 9, 2014

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

CMS makes changes to reporting deadlines and requirements, Canada continues to collect date about the effects of off-label use of drugs, and Medicines Australia updates its Code of Conduct.

You scream, I scream, we all scream for ice cream! And we’ll be doing a lot of screaming because July is National Ice Cream Month. (July – 31 days. Baskin-Robbins – 31 flavors. Coincidence?) Whether on a cone, in a cup or topped with sauces, fruit or confections, July is a great month to enjoy this cold treat. And gone are the days when Tutti Frutti was the outrageous flavor. Now, along with the likes of Cookies & Cream and Rum Raisin, you can have your pick of Chocolate-Chili, Roasted Garlic, or Mushy Green Peas. As you ponder your favorite flavor (bizarre or otherwise) for beating the July heat, we offer our own scoop with this week’s News in Review.

The deadline for submitting Phase 2 data melted away, sort of, last week. CMS sent out an email essentially extending the deadline for submitting Open Payments Phase 2 documents to July 7. In the e-mail, CMS said it wanted to assure accuracy and completeness of the reports and attestations and that penalties would not be enforced for non-compliance until after July 7.

Also melting away could be the CME exclusion in final rule for the Sunshine Act. CMS is planning to propose a change to the exemption for reporting CME payments. The current rule allows an exemption for three reasons: the program is accredited by certain organizations, the physician isn’t paid directly by the manufacturer, or the manufacturer doesn’t influence the selection of speakers. CMS ultimately decided to remove the exclusion due to the redundancies involving indirect payments that occur when the manufacturer is unaware of the recipient. The agency also does not want to appear that it is indicating support of certain accrediting bodies by continuing to specifically name them in the exemption. The proposed changes will appear in the July 11 Federal Register.

And if the CME change isn’t enough, CMS has a few other toppings to add to the final rule sundae. The agency is also proposing that “stock, stock options, and other ownership interests” not be one category, but three. Other changes include the requirement that all manufacturers, including device manufacturers, use the product’s marketed name on reports and the removal of the “definition of a covered device” from the rule.

Canada’s Health Minister, Rona Ambrose, is serving up a scoop or two of new information about serious side effects resulting from off-label drug use. Health Canada has been collecting the information for several years, but technical issues prevented it from making the database of information publicly available. The group is planning a systems upgrade that will allow the regulator to share the database. No timeline for when the public can expect to access the information has been released.

Medicines Australia is looking for approval of its latest flavor. The organization has submitted the 18th edition of its Code of Conduct to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission for authorization. The new Code includes requirements for the reporting of transfers of value from industry to healthcare professionals. If authorized, the Code will become effective January 2015, with the new transparency requirements going into effect October of 2015. However, not everyone is happy with the result. A provision requiring manufacturers to obtain permission from physicians to allow their name to be published with the payment data, has members of the Greens political party very concerned. A spokesman said the party was considering reintroducing legislation to make the reporting of transfers of value to physicians a legal requirement.

Sunshine and transparency will no doubt continue to be a popular flavor, both here and abroad, for the distant future. That’s why we are adding a global transparency focused module to our growing list of PharmaCertify™ off-the-shelf learning solutions. To learn more about the module or see a content outline, contact Sean Murphy at smurphy@nxlevelsolutions.com.

Have a great rest of the week!

Week in Review, June 09, 2014

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

France publishes its first public reports related to physician payments, several companies pay out millions in settlement fines,  medical affairs professionals discuss their changing role in compliance, and Massachusetts releases a notice regarding the reporting of the same spend information required under the Sunshine Act.

Break out the mortarboard and fire up Pomp and Circumstance, it’s that time of year again. has arrived. There’s nothing quite like watching the graduates cross that stage, receive their diploma and bask in the achievement. Here’s hoping they enjoy the moment before they have to face the harsh realities of the next phase of life. (Remember that moment when we realized that “nap time” in first grade did not include a mat? Welcome to the real world!) With that in mind, we proudly present this week’s graduating class…and this week’s compliance News in Review.

A transfer story from France leads our parade of worthy stories. France has published the first public reports of industry transfers of value (TOVs) to healthcare professionals, as required by the French Sunshine Act. To manipulate this database you’ll need to dust off your old French text book, or quickly invest in a Rosetta Stone course, because there is no option to switch to an English (or any other language for that matter) translation. The company information is all .txt files that are practically impossible to read, but if you know some HCPs in France you’d like to search for, that information is slightly more reader friendly…except for the whole being in French thing. Oh well, the information is there for the linguistic and inquisitive among us. According to the folks at Policy and Medicine, there has been little press coverage of the release of the data.

Don’t get to comfortable with the French Sunshine Act though, it appears there may be a major change coming soon. Recently, the Ministry of Social Affairs of Healthcare issued a draft order that would modify some of the regulations. One modification will simplify the details reported about HCP arrangements. Another will lessen the level to which companies need to protect HCP information. Finally, a change to the schedule initially set up to declare the benefits and the conventions has been proposed.

Several industry companies are facing unexpected fees and fines. Medtronic will pay $9.9 million to settle allegations under the False Claims Act. According to the government, the company used a variety of payment schemes to induce physicians to use its pacemakers and defibrillators. The company is alleged to have paid physicians to speak at events to increase referral business, created marketing/business development plans for physicians at no cost, and provided sporting event tickets to physicians.

Boehringer Ingleheim has agreed to pay $650 million to settle 4,000 lawsuits involving the drug, Pradaxa. According to a BI spokesperson, the average payout per settlement will be $162,500. Plaintiffs claim the company didn’t adequately warn patients of the risks associated with use of the blood thinner. The company says the drug’s safety has been repeatedly demonstrated, and the settlement does not change the drug plays in patients’ lives.

GSK has agreed to pay $105 million to 44 states and the District of Columbia to settle claims they illegally promoted two antidepressants and an asthma drug. In the agreement with the states, the company agreed to changes in its incentives to sales people, not use paid physicians to promote products, and to refrain from making deceptive or misleading statements in its advertising.

Chicago is throwing its cap in the ring and has filed suit against five manufacturers of highly addictive painkillers. In a suit similar to one filed by several California counties, Chicago is claiming the companies overstated the benefits and downplayed the risks associated with the use of the pain drugs. The suit says the companies violated laws related to consumer fraud, misleading advertising and false claims. In addition to the civil penalties and punitive damages, the city is seeking to reclaim profits associated with the illegal marketing activity.

As the regulatory landscape changes, medical affairs personnel are becoming more important in conversations with HCPs and more involved with health economic and outcomes research (HEOR). Within these two areas, concerns regarding off-label use of products are becoming a hot issue. Speakers at last week’s World Congress said their companies have evolved their policies on responding to unsolicited requests for off-label information. Compliance issues related to HEOR include the nature of the studies used and whether or not the company is providing payers with balanced information regarding the safety and efficacy of products.

Massachusetts has finally moved the tassel on some of its HCP spend reporting requirements. The state recently released a Notice of Federal Preemption, which stated that the Department of Public Health could not require pharmaceutical and med device companies to report the same spend information that is required by the Sunshine Act.

And with that, we bring this week’s ceremony to a resounding close. We wish all of the graduates out there good luck with whatever life holds for them next. Toss those caps in the air everyone and have a great week! We’ll see you right back here next week.

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

News Week in Review, April 1, 2014

Signs of sunshine in Canada, the DOJ issues its first FCPA advisory opinion of 2014, and the Serious Fraud office faces growing challenges in the enforcement of the UK Bribery Act.

April showers bring May flowers…and we are certainly ready for some flowers! Really, any sign that spring is here to stay would be appreciated. We’re even looking forward to a little spring cleaning as long as the spring part comes along with the cleaning part. So with visions of daffodils dancing in our heads, and the chill of winter fading from our memories, we bring you the compliance news of the week, with the News in Review.

Those May flowers may even have a little Sunshine added to the mix in Canada. Two Canadian physicians think the Ontario Minister of Health should require pharma companies with drugs on public formulary to disclose their financial relationships with physicians. As justification, the physicians claim other transparency initiatives in the country have proven to be both beneficial and popular and studies have shown that even small tokens, such as pens and note pads, influence decision making.

The DOJ’s first FCPA advisory opinion of 2014 has sprouted. The FCPA opinion procedure allows entities to seek an opinion from the Attorney General on whether a specific situation is in line with the DOJ’s current enforcement of the anti-bribery provisions of the law. This particular opinion was in response to a financial services provider and investor bank asking if a payment due to an individual when the individual was a private citizen could be considered illegal if the individual now is a foreign official.

The Serious Fraud Office continues to face stormy weather following the disintegration of the high-profile bribery case against Victor Dahdahel. In addition to the negative publicity around the failed prosecution, the agency has faced significant cuts in funding; increasing pressure to secure convictions under the Bribery Act; and growing questions about how it expects to obtain evidence from jurisdictions outside the U.K.

The seeds of clinical trial transparency are taking root, according to the European Federation of Pharmaceutical Industries and Associations (EFPIA). EFPIA recently provided an update on the adoption of the joint EFPIA-PhRMA principle on clinical trial transparency. According to the announcement, several companies, including Pfizer, UCB and Sanofi, have all taken steps to make the results of their clinical trials publicly available. Pfizer has expanded its policies on data sharing and Sanofi will be participating in a multi-company web portal designed to share clinical trial data. UCB revealed its plans for adoption of the principles in a publicly accessible webinar.

The Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons is looking to eliminate the need for Sunshine. Proposed guidelines from the influential regulator will put a stop to the practice of physicians accepting gifts or items of value from the industry and will prohibit doctors from having articles ghostwritten by pharmaceutical companies. The guidelines will allow doctors to accept lunches, patient education items, drug samples, and funds for educational programs. Physicians will also be permitted to serve as speakers or consultants. Critics say the proposed guidelines offer nothing in the way of true reform.

Not only does the end of March signal the start of spring, it brings us the deadline for submitting Phase I Sunshine reports. Now that you’ve cleared that hurdle and you have time to stop and smell the roses, have you considered sprucing up your Sunshine training? The Sunshine Act: The Federal Physician Spend Disclosure Law from the PharmaCertify™ suite of compliance training modules, offers the updated training your staff needs to understand the law’s disclosure requirements.

Have a great week everyone!

Week in Review, February 17, 2014

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

A look back at 2013 FCPA enforcement reveals trends for the future, Brazil enacts an anti-bribery law of its own, at least one attorney wonders if Sunshine will hamper qui tam cases, and the FDA wants medical device adverse event reports submitted electronically.

Well, it’s President’s Day – certainly, one of the more interesting American holidays in terms of its evolution. From what we’re told by the folks at the history channel, the holiday was originally created to celebrate George Washington’s birthday. The shift to “President’s Day” is somewhat convoluted but suffice to say, it was part of the Uniform Monday Holiday, which was passed in 1971 and was intended to create more three day weekends for the nation’s workers, while fighting employee absenteeism by ensuring that holidays fell on the same weekday. Whew! Now that we are all clear on that, let’s focus on something a lot easier to understand, the compliance news of the week, in the News in Review.

Speaking of history, we begin this week with a look back at the DOJ’s enforcement of the FCPA for clues to future trends. Not surprisingly, the scope of FCPA enforcement widened in 2013, and the average cost of resolving increased to $80 million last year. New industries felt the brunt of the Act, with apparel manufacturer, Ralph Lauren, and ATM manufacturer, Diebold, entering into settlements with the government to settle charges. The agencies also expanded their investigatory search beyond written documents to business communication in general, with one representative of a mining company being charged with witness tampering based on a secretly recorded conversation.

A new bribery law  had its inauguration at the end of January. Brazil’s Clean Companies Act went into effect on January 29th. The law allows for the prosecution of  acts of bribery committed by Brazilian companies or foreign companies with a registered affiliate in Brazil. Unlike the FCPA and UK Bribery Act, the Clean Companies Act only carries civil penalties.

Holiday or not, Teva may not be a celebratory mood. The company announced it was under investigation by the government for the marketing practices related to two of its drugs. The government requested documents dating back to 2006 as it conducts the investigation.

From the land adjacent to the “land of Lincoln” comes an announcement of a program designed to educate medical students about the inner workings of the pharmaceutical industry. Eli Lilly is rolling out a four week rotational program where students will experience the various aspects of the drug development process and how physicians contribute to that process. The program will be conducted at Tulane University’s School of Medicine.

On the legal front, during a National Disclosure Summit, a qui tam attorney said Sunshine data could hamper qui tam cases more than it could help. The attorney said relators will have a harder time getting past the False Claims Act “public disclosure bar,” which requires relators to file their claims before information is in the public domain. On the other hand, the Sunshine data will add instant credibility to  a whistleblower’s claims, according to the same attorney. The data can also support an “inference of off-label marketing.”

The FDA announced that beginning in August of 2015, adverse event reports related to medical devices will need to be submitted electronically. The move, which is part of an initiative to improve operations, is expected to save the FDA $1.9 million each year. Companies will save too, but only after an estimated $38 – $42 million dollar investment to upgrade their own systems and procedures.

And so ends this week’s News in Review. With the end of another February in site, now is the time to launch updated product promotion training for 2014. The customizable PharmaCertify™ eLearning module, Good Promotional Practices offers the training your field staff needs on critical topics like gifts, meals and entertainment; advisory boards; and speaker programs.

Have a great week everyone!

 

Week in Review, January 28, 2014

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunshine and state-accredited CME are clarified at a conference, the Supreme Court weighs in on medical device patent infringement, China institutes a new program to monitor healthcare and a new study shows the industry is still wary of social media.

Go west, young man…if you want to escape this arctic cold that is. It was another week of super cold weather, snow showing up in unlikely locales (you saw all the memes about Austin, TX, right?), frozen pipes and below zero wind chills. When Anchorage, Alaska is warmer than Atlanta, GA, you know we’re having cold weather here in the east. To make matters worse, another blast of arctic cold is on the way. The only escape seems to be the western part of the country, where temperatures in the 80’s and sunshine are thriving. The rest of us will just have to huddle around the fireplace and catch up on all things compliance, with this week’s News in Review.

The topic of Sunshine and state-accredited CME programs heated things up at a recent continuing education conference. A CMS representative speaking at the conference mistakenly indicated that state accredited CME programs were not exempt under Sunshine. The final rule actually refers to both certified and accredited CME and does not draw any clear lines between the two distinctions. After hearing how the process actually works, the CMS representative realized that the state-accredited CME would qualify for exemption.

The U.S. Supreme Court iced out patent holders in a recent decision. The Court unanimously ruled that patent holders bear the burden of proof in patent infringement cases, even if they received a declaratory judgment. The case at the center of the ruling involved Medtronic and Mirowski Family Ventures,LLC. Mirowski holds patents for implantable heart stimulators, and Medtronic had a license agreement to use those patents. The company claimed Medtronic infringed its patents, but a federal court ruled Mirowski  had not met the burden of proving infringement. The case was appealed and a U.S. Court of Appeals reversed the ruling, saying Mirowski set the events in motion and that there was “no convincing reason why burden of proof law should favor the patentee.”

The FDA has discovered a new way to submit nominations for its advisory committees. The agency announced the launch of an interactive online portal for the submission of advisory committee nominations. Applicants can submit their entire application through the new portal. The FDA says the system will eliminate confusion and accelerate timelines for submission and acceptance.

China is cranking up the thermostat with a campaign to deal with bad manufacturing and marketing practices in healthcare. The inter-departmental campaign involves eight different departments in the Chinese government. Officials hope to also use the program to deepen reform efforts in medical services.

A new report shows much of the industry still feels chilly about social media. The report from IMS Health indicated that 23 of the top 50 companies worldwide are using Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. However, only 10 of the companies are using all three, and very few are using social media to engage patients. Most are using social media as a way to deliver messages intended for providers and patients alike. Companies with a small therapeutic focus tend to use social media more to engage the patient. In an interesting twist, the study also found that regulators are quite active on social media. The FDA and EMA post high index reach scores, and the FDA scored higher than any pharmaceutical company on IMS’ relationship scale.

We certainly hope everyone stays warm and safe as the next arctic express heads east. We’ll be venturing out into it ourselves for CBI’S 11th Annual Pharmaceutical Compliance Congress. If you’re there, stop by our booth in the exhibit hall to say  hi and see a demo of our new Compliance Curriculum Refresher Training series.

Stay warm everyone!

News Week in Review, December 10, 2013

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Studies reveal non-clinician HCPs have a favorable view of industry relationship, AstraZeneca partners with Harvard to improve drug testing, and the focus on the FCPA intensifies.

Well, the year is almost over, and if you’re like us, you’re probably wondering how December got here so fast and what happened to the rest of 2013. Before we put another year in the books though, we at least have the usual list of holiday movies and specials to enjoy. While you search the listings and set your DVRs to record, we’ll deliver a little entertainment of our own, with this week’s News in Review.

In terms of their relationships with the industry, non-physician clinicians generally feel It’s a Wonderful Life, albeit one with the potential for risks and conflicts of interest. An analysis of multiple studies related to the industry and non-physician HCPs like registered nurses, nurse prescribers, and Physician Assistants, shows the providers typically have a favorable view of industry interactions and say they rely on industry representatives for important information. The authors of the review suggest institutions expand policies on industry interactions and the Sunshine Act to include non-clinician HCPs.

AstraZeneca researchers will Deck the Halls with researchers at Harvard. The company announced they will collaborate with the institution on an initiative to improve drug testing in humans. The technology, called Organs on Chips, uses human cells in a flexible polymer to imitate human organs. The two organizations will work to develop an animal version of the technology that will then be used to compare drug testing results between humans and animals.

Santa Claus is Comin’ to Town, with early gifts, by way of Vermont and CMS. The Vermont AG’s office released a memo announcing the 2013 disclosure forms and databases will be ready sometime this week, and that the draft guidance for 2014 will be released soon. A conference call to discuss the guidance will be held December 19. CMS posted several documents to the Open Payments website, including XML and CSD schema for reports and sample report examples.

Some in the industry might say the Department of Justice and Securities and Exchange Commission are acting more and more like Scrooge when it comes to FCPA investigations. According to the head of the DOJ’s FCPA Unit, the DOJ is investigating 150 cases and expects to bring “very significant cases” in 2014. The SEC has received over 3,000 whistleblower tips involving FCPA investigations and with cooperation increasing globally, regulators expect the prosecution of individuals for FCPA violations to continue.

Was that The Grinch Who Stole Christmas lurking about the offices of Reckitt Benckiser? Perhaps it was one of the agents from the OIG and IRS who removed boxes of documents from the company’s offices in Virginia. A company spokesperson confirmed that a warrant was served by the US Attorney’s Office for Western Virginia, and that the company was cooperating with the investigation. The purpose for the warrant was not disclosed.

Employees at Advance Sterilization Products haven’t been feeling merry lately. The FDA announced a $1.25 million settlement with the company and two of its executives for the selling of adulterated and misbranded product. The FDA claims the company knew it did not have sufficient data to support the expiration date on its sterilization monitoring product.

That brings us to the end of the News in Review for this week. As you close out 2013 and finalize your compliance curriculum for next year, remember the PharmaCertify™ suite of eLearning modules and mobile apps offer your staff the up-to-date content they need where and when they need it most – in the field and at their fingertips.

Have a great week everyone!

Week in Review, November 4, 2013

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Week in Review, November 4, 2013
The FDA explores the Bad Ad program, targeting misleading drug ads for younger audiences; whistleblower cases shed light on Cephalon kickbacks and the government steps up corruption investigations.

It’s the most wonderful time of the year! When we’re nestled all snug in our beds with visions of sugarplums (or dew drops) dancing in our heads. Finally, Daylight Savings Time came to end over the weekend! Oh, the joy of receiving that precious hour back. We hope you made the most of that “free” hour over the weekend. We sure did! The back of eyelids never looked so good. It’s back to the grind now, so let’s get rolling with this week’s News Week in Review.

The FDA has decided it’s about time to study how teens perceive direct drug advertising. The study will gauge how teens respond to ads for fictitious acne and ADHD drugs. Studies have shown that the part of the brain that helps in discerning risk in decision making is not fully developed until the mid-twenties. The FDA wants to understand how teenagers judge the risk and benefits associated with the drugs in the ads to determine if changes should be made in the way certain drugs are advertised online.

The FDA has sprung forward with a new CME program as a part of the Bad Ad program. The agency will launch a web-based CME program to teach HCPs how to identify misleading drug ads. The course will focus on various types of advertising, and is open to anyone, even though it’s directed to HCPs.

The government will fall back from a pair of whistleblower cases against Cephalon. The first whistleblower case focuses on the off-label promotion of four drugs Cephalon co-promoted with Takeda. This is the second case brought by this group of whistleblowers against the company. The first case resulted in a settlement. In the second, the relator alleges Cephalon promoted three drugs for off-label purposes and paid kickbacks to doctors. The relator also alleges Cephalon and WebMD conspired to locate certain patient populations and promote drugs for off-label use to those patients.

A study by Taxpayers Against Fraud found that for every dollar the federal government spends on investigating and prosecuting healthcare fraud, it recovers $16. The study showed that between 2008 and 2012 civil, criminal and state recoveries were just over $18 billion. The study also showed that since 1987, recoveries totaled nearly $40 billion. China, the U.K. and U.S. are not dilly-dallying when it comes to corruption investigations. Speakers at a conference in Beijing said the countries are stepping up corruption investigations in the food and drug industry. This year, the U.S. government initiated 11 FCPA investigations of drug and medical device companies. According to a former DOJ official speaking at the conference, the agency believes there is considerable corruption occurring in drug firms overseas, and addressing it is a priority with the DOJ. John Tan, counsel with international law firm Reed Smith, said the Serious Fraud Office has six Bribery Act investigations under consideration.

Don’t overlook the importance of having administrative assistants spend time on anti-corruption training. Addressing the question of who should be included in FCPA training, the FCPA Professor points out that while administrative assistants may not interact with “foreign officials” directly, they can be a valuable asset in identifying FCPA risks if they receive training. The article references a recent article in the WSJ about the influence and power admins hold, and points out this should not be overlooked when determining your FCPA training audience.

Well, the clock has run out on another issue of the Week in Review. If all of this news surrounding product promotion has you wondering if your field force is up-to-date on the latest compliance practices, Good Promotional Practices from the PharmaCertify™ suite of customizable off-the-shelf eLearning modules, covers topics ranging from gifts and meals to speaker programs and the handling of off-label inquiries.

Have a great week everyone!

Week in Review, October 21, 2013

NXLevel Compliance Team , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

A U.S Senator calls for an investigation into the relationship between pharmaceutical companies and the FDA, the definition of “foreign official” under the FCPA is debated in Florida, the Baycol False Claims Act case moves forward and 25 manufacturers settle with Vermont over charges of failing to file required reports.

The World Series gets underway this Wednesday with the Cardinals returning after a one year hiatus to face a scraggly, scrappy Red Sox squad. With the team from Boston representing the American League, no doubt the boys from St. Louis have gained a new legion of fans in New York. So, do you have a side in the battle, or will you just be glad when it’s over, and you can get back to The New Girl and Sleepy Hollow? Whether you’re looking forward to the first pitch or the last, we’re here to help fill the time with the current version of the News in Review.

U.S. Senator, Joe Manchin, has put a call into a different type of commissioner to investigate an alleged pay-for-play scheme between the FDA and pharmaceutical companies. In the letter to FDA commissioner Margaret Hamburg, Senator Manchin expresses concern about reports of pharmaceutical companies paying thousands of dollars to attend FDA advisory meetings about the safety of pain medication. He would like to see a full senate investigation into the allegations to shed light on whether the relationship between pharma companies and the FDA caused any delay in the rescheduling of addictive pain killers.

A meeting on the mound is needed to settle an FCPA case in Florida. The case is now in the hands of three judges, and at the crux of the discussion is everyone’s favorite topic – the definition of a foreign official. More specifically, the case focuses on the definition of an “instrumentality.” Two telecom executives are accused of bribing the government-owned Haiti Teleco and defense lawyers have argued that an instrumentality has to be a direct part of the government under the FCPA, which is not the case with Haiti Teleco.

Internal controls charges are on the rise in FCPA cases, leading the Cadwalader law firm to wonder if the DOJ and SEC are poised to begin charging independent directors for failing to assure or maintain proper controls. Several companies have faced such charges recently, and as was demonstrated in the Orthofix case, companies can be charged with a violation for not having financial controls or an adequate compliance program in place. The FCPA guidance states that compliance begins with board members and senior executives, so the idea of independent directors being charged for the lack of proper controls isn’t far-fetched.

Upon further review, a whistleblower case against Bayer will move forward, but only on the grounds that the Department of Defense was defrauded, not federal healthcare programs. The False Claims Act case, which alleges that Bayer was deceptive in its marketing of Baycol, was dismissed last year because the court said the whistleblower failed to meet the specificity threshold related to false claims. The appeals court reversed the lower court’s decision.

Boston Scientific and its Guidant division have agreed to pay $30 million to settle charges of knowingly selling defective heart devices to facilities that treat Medicare patients. The government alleged that despite being aware of the problem, Guidant continued to sell defective stock and sent misleading communications to doctors in attempt to hide the true nature of the defect. The government also alleged that Guidant attempted to hide the defect from the FDA.

Vermont racked up 25 strikes against manufacturers under its Prescribed Products Gift Ban and Reporting law. The state’s Attorney General recently announced settlements with 25 manufacturers for alleged violations of the law. Most of the companies involved were small manufacturers and most of the charges levied were for failure to file the required reports. One manufacturer faced six charges of violating the gift ban.

We close with a reminder that the PharmaCertify team will be on-site at the Fourteenth Annual Pharmaceutical Regulatory and Compliance Congress next week. So if you’re attending, don’t forget to stop by the booth, say hi, and ask about our suite of compliance training modules and apps.

Have a great week everyone.